First of all, Great choice of shoes.  My routine is to wipe them off at the course and put shoe trees in them right away.  As for cleaning, I use saddle soap, let them dry and then give them a good polish with a creme based polish, not a wax base.

After a round a always wipe them down with a damp towel to get any excess dirt or mud off.  When I get home I wipe them down with a towel and Meguiar's Gold Class Rich Leather Cleaner/Conditioner.  Then I store them in a shoe bag with shoe trees in.  I've been doing this for years and all of my shoes still look brand new.

The Mr. Clean magic erasers does wonders 

I don't have any evidence, but I'm not sure I would use the magic eraser on my shoes.  Won't that thing remove paint?  I would think it would be too abrasive for leather shoes.  I could be completely wrong and maybe others have more knowledge/experience with this, and if so, hopefully they will chime in.

I have never cleaned FJ Icons but I have white 14's and I used "Simple Green" to clean them and it worked like a charm!

Hope this helps,

Davis

Hi Rodney 

the way I clean my 24 pairs of fj,s ranging from classic,s, icons, dry joys to dry joys casuals, is clean them soapy water dry them off . Then I use Footjoy Polish & leave the polish to dry then buff them with a soft shoe brush. 

Stuart l

Soapy water, a soft towel, and "Awesome" cleaner (available at most dollar stores) always work well together.

WW